Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

The Most Common Smoke Detector Mistakes Homeowners Make

September 20th, 2025

4 min read

By Daniel Carpenter

smoke detector with big red X over it. Red text that says
The Most Common Smoke Detector Mistakes Homeowners Make
6:28

It’s easy to forget about your smoke detectors until you need them.

For most homeowners, these devices quietly sit on the ceiling, barely noticed and rarely tested. But that small, round unit could be the first and only warning you get in a fire. When it fails, it’s often not because the technology didn’t work… but because of a mistake that could’ve been prevented.

At Integra Electrical, we help homeowners across Central Iowa catch small issues before they become big emergencies. And smoke detectors are one of the most overlooked parts of a home’s safety system. Whether you’ve lived in your home for years or just moved in, knowing what to look for can keep your family safe and give you peace of mind.

The 6 mistakes with smoke alarms are:

Mistake #1: Putting Detectors in the Wrong Locations

A smoke detector only works if it’s placed where smoke can reach it.
We’ve seen detectors buried in corners, shoved near vents, or missing from bedrooms entirely.
Here’s where to put them according to the code:

  • Inside every bedroom
  • Outside each sleeping area (like a hallway)
  • On every level, including basements

Here’s where not to put them:

  • Near bathrooms or kitchens (false alarms)
  • Near windows, fans, or vents (airflow blocks smoke)
  • Too low on walls or angled ceilings

High up is good. Directly above your toaster? Not so much.

Mistake #2: Not Replacing Old Detectors

If your smoke detector is older than your high schooler, it’s time to say goodbye. (And unlike a teen, it doesn’t get to stay just because it occasionally makes noise and sleeps all day.)

Detectors expire after 10 years, even if they seem fine. Sensors wear down. Test buttons can give a false sense of security.

Check yours by:

  • Taking it off the ceiling
  • Looking for a manufacture date on the back
  • Replacing it if it’s over 10 years old, or so yellow it matches your ‘90s linoleum

New models are smarter, quieter, and easier to live with. Some even hush themselves. Your old detector? It just sits there and judges your burnt popcorn.

Mistake #3: Disabling Detectors Due to False Alarms

You made bacon. The smoke alarm lost its mind. You yanked the battery. We get it, but now it’s useless. Disabling your smoke detector because it’s “annoying” is like unplugging your seatbelt because it’s too tight.

False alarms usually mean:

  • It’s too close to the stove or shower
  • It’s an old, overly dramatic model
  • It’s the wrong type (photoelectric is best near kitchens)

Try moving it, upgrading it, or getting one with a hush button. Don’t just remove the battery and hope for the best. Because one day it won’t be bacon, it’ll be something worse.

Mistake #4: Forgetting to Test Monthly

Smoke detectors don’t have calendars. They can’t remind you to check them, you’ve got to remember. Testing once a month takes 10 seconds. Press the button. Wait for the beep. Done. If it doesn’t beep, it’s time for a battery or a replacement.

Want a reminder? Test when you pay your power bill or the first Saturday of every month. Better yet, get the kids to do it. It’s loud, mildly terrifying, and oddly fun.

Most people assume their detectors are working just because they haven’t gone off. But silence isn’t proof. It just means nothing yet has caught fire.

Mistake #5: Relying Only on Battery Power

Battery-powered smoke detectors are common, and they do work. But they’re also easier to forget about, especially when that little 9-volt quietly dies behind the scenes.

That’s why most experts (and code requirements in newer homes) recommend hardwired smoke detectors with battery backup. These stay powered even if someone forgets to replace a battery or the power goes out.

If you want extra peace of mind, consider interconnected detectors. That means if one alarm goes off, say, in the basement, all the alarms go off, waking up the whole house.
Battery-only models are fine as a starting point. But for full-coverage safety, hardwiring with a backup makes sure nothing slips through the cracks.

Mistake #6: Mixing Up Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Detectors

They might look the same, but they do very different jobs.

Smoke detectors alert you to fires. Carbon monoxide detectors warn you about a deadly gas you can’t see or smell. One won’t catch what the other is meant to detect, so no, you can’t pick just one and hope for the best. If your home uses gas appliances, has a fireplace, or has an attached garage, you absolutely need carbon monoxide detectors.

Not sure what you have? Check the label, some units are combination detectors, which is great! Just make sure you have enough of them, and that they’re placed correctly.

  • Smoke detectors: high on walls or ceilings

  • CO detectors: near all sleeping areas and within 15-25 feet of fuel-burning appliances.

It’s not about doubling up. It’s about covering all your bases.

What to Do Next

Smoke detectors don’t need to be complicated, but they do need to work. If you’re not sure yours are installed right or doing their job, a quick check today could make all the difference.

Quick Safety Checklist:

  • Installed in every bedroom and hallway
  • Less than 10 years old
  • Tested monthly
  • Not disconnected due to false alarms
  • Hardwired with battery backup if possible
  • CO detectors installed if needed

If you're unsure what you have, or what you need, our team at Integra Electrical offers free home safety evaluations. We’ll walk you through it with zero pressure, just honest answers and options that fit your home.

Smoke Detector Frequently Asked Questions

How many smoke detectors do I need?

At minimum: one inside each bedroom, one outside each sleeping area, and one on every level of the home, including the basement.

Do smoke detectors really expire?

Yes. Most need to be replaced every 10 years, even if they still beep when tested.

What’s the difference between photoelectric and ionization detectors?

Photoelectric models are better at catching smoldering fires (and less likely to falsely alarm from cooking). Ionization models respond faster to open flames.

Daniel Carpenter

Daniel Carpenter is a licensed electrician on Integra’s installation team. He got his license at just 19, but he's been around the trade his whole life. With five years on the job and a heart for helping homeowners, Daniel takes pride in doing quality work that serves the local community.